Premiere's Top 20 Most Overrated Films of All Time
American Beauty -- agree, although I only saw the TV version, I don't think that just being morbidly depressing is enough to make a "great" movie. Basically a better version of "The Weather Man".
Chicago -- agree, while it is a fairly well done musical, I never understood the Oscar buzz
Clerks. -- agree, I never understood the claims that the film was a work of genius, I think it was Roger Ebert who once said that critics crave anything that is new and different to keep them awake. I think "Clerks" fell into that category
Fantasia -- disagree, was far, far ahead of its time
Field of Dreams -- as a sports fan I have to disagree, I also don't know if "overrated" would apply since many critics when it came out were VERY negative
Chariots of Fire -- agree, maybe the most boring movie ever made
Good Will Hunting -- could not disagree more, one of my favorite 5 movies of all time
Forrest Gump -- when I watched it 10 years ago I would say agree, but I watched it last year -- as you get 40+ you start to understand the point of the movie. Now I am in the disagree camp.
Jules and Jim -- disagree, I have never heard of the movie, so it isn't overrated in my mind
A Beautiful Mind -- disagree, the movie is very well acted and gives a great insight into mental illness. Crowe and Jennifer Connolly are both great.
Monster's Ball -- agree, I think the whole Halle Berry nude deal just sent guys over the edge
Moonstruck -- agree, a nice pleasant screwball comedy, but Best Picture? Best Actress?
Mystic River -- disagree, brutal, brutal film, but not at all overrated...................................
Nashville -- agree, not that good.........................................................
The Wizard of Oz -- isn't this a bit like criticizing a Model T for not having great acceleration? In 1939 it was a marvel and it kept kids entertained for 60 years. The fact that the my kids now don't think much of it is irrelevant
An American in Paris -- agree
Easy Rider -- agree
The Red Shoes -- disagree, never heard of it.
2001: A Space Odyssey -- agree
Gone with the Wind -- disagree, a stupid choice, it was so well-received in its day that its inflation-adjusted U.S. box office is like $1.5 billion.